Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

« Previous Version 60 Next »

As organisations begin to use GSIM, this discussion forum will be used to explore issues with the model or propose extensions to the model.

 

 

Discussion Forum

Add new discussion topic

Log (to be updated by Thérèse Lalor only)

TopicBackground
Object/ Issue
Raised byLast comment
Status
Outcome
Comment
Methodology#17BMethodologyThérèse Lalor27 AugustOPEN TOPICDan is going to provide a use case, then we will discuss futher if changes need to be made. 
Data set#24Distinguishing between different types of datasetsJenny Linnerud

16 Aug

OPEN TOPIC  
Quality#17AQualityThérèse Lalor30 AugustOPEN TOPICWim and ABS is going to review current user guide content. 
Documentation#25GSIMv2 documentationThérèse Lalor---OPEN TOPIC  
        
Non Structured Dataset#6Non Structured Data SetThérèse Lalor13 AugOPEN TOPICleaning towards removing object 
Modelling#14RelationshipsJenny Linnerud---OPEN TOPICAction: All relationships need to be reviewed and made explicit before next releasePlace holder
Modelling#22AttributesThérèse Lalor---OPEN TOPICAction: All attributes need to be reviewed and made explicit before next releasePlace holder
Reference Metadata#17CReference MetadataThérèse Lalor---OPEN TOPIC  
        
Methodology#3Design ContextJenny Linnerud16 JulWAITING (Waiting for Methodology discussion to happen before decision made)
Data Set#7

unit data

dimensional data

Thérèse Lalor02 JulWAITING Alistair Hamilton
Node Sets#12Hierarchy in Classifications and codelistsHelen Toole06 AugWAITINGChris providing example of hierarchical codelist as exampleChris Nelson
Views of GSIM#15Creating views of GSIMGareth McGuinness18 JulWAITING Waiting for input from CSPA
Index/Index Entry#26Index/Index EntryThérèse Lalor27 AugWAITING Use case being created by Canadawaiting for Neuchatel group
        
Population

#1

 

Add unit type object

Alistair Hamilton

 

01 JulDECIDED

A new object will be added called Unit Type

Action: Definition, relationships and attributed need to be drafted

 
#13Survey and Frame PopulationsJenny Linnerud27 AugDECIDED

All subtypes of population will be removed

All subtypes of Unit will be remove

 
#16Add relationship to unit typeHelen Toole4 JunDECIDEDAction: Relationship to Logical Record to be added 

Node Sets



#2

Code vs Code List

Category vs Category Set

Klas Blomqvist 13 AugDECIDED

Provide clearer explanation of the differences

Code is kept in the model with better explanation

Action: Text needs to be drafted from examples in discussion forum

 

#8

LevelHelen Toole26 MarDECIDED

Change the diagrams to include Level in the next release.

Action: New diagrams to be created

 
#11Statistical Classification CardinalityHelen Toole

22 Apr

DECIDED

Classification Scheme (Statistical Classification) has Mandatory Level

Action: Change the definition of (Statistical Classification) such that it must contain at least one Level.

(Statistical Classification) 1..* Level (Mandatory, Many)

 
#21Alignment with NeuchatelThérèse Lalor13 AugDECIDED

Change according to proposal

Action:

Remove Classification Version from model

Remove Classification Variant from model

Change Classification to Classification Series

Change Classification Scheme to Statistical Classification

Revise relationships according to proposal

Add attributes according to proposal

Revise definitions

 
Business Service#4

Business Service

Dissemination Service

Thérèse Lalor09 AprDECIDED

Dissemination Service to be a subtype of Business Service

Action: Text needs to be drafted and attributes aligned

 
Data Resource#5States of dataJenny Linnerud31 JulDECIDED

Information about how states of data "could be done" should go into the next version of the User Guide, rather than trying to fit into the model

Input to be given by countries using states of data may be done.

Action: Text needs to be drafted

 

Data Channel#9Data ChannelThérèse Lalor03 JulDECIDED

Data Channel stays in model

Action: Review definition of Data Channel

 
Representation#10RepresentationThérèse Lalor09 AprDECIDED

Change name of Representation to Presentation

Action: Name changed in documentation and model

 
Data Point#18Data PointHelen Toole16 JulDECIDED

Example in glossary to be fixed (Proposal 1)

Action: Fix Example

 
Process Output#19Add Process Output subtypeGareth McGuinness27 AugDECIDED

 Remove all subtypes of Process Input

Remove all subtypes of Process Output

 
Assessment#20AssessmentGareth McGuinness16 JulDECIDED

Definition to be improved

Action: Fix definition

 
Data Provider#23Data ProviderJenny Linnerud13 AugDECIDED

No change to model required. Although perhaps clarification in text would help future users?

Action: clarification in text would help future users?

 

 

 

Open Issues

Topics 40 Replies 206
Topic Author Replies Last Reply
 
 
As raised during the meeting, formally defining Dissemination Service as a subtype of Business
Thérèse Lalor 25 Feb 5 Alistair Hamilton 09 Apr
 
I think we discussed this in the past - the relationship between a population and an object
Alistair Hamilton 01 Feb 18 Dan Gillman 22 Nov
 
Option from Chris. It is the same as Option except that in option 1 Logical record and record
Thérèse Lalor 04 Oct 5 Thérèse Lalor 16 Nov
 
GSIM and Metadata Structures.docx Input from Chris attached. Extra work required to make
Thérèse Lalor 03 Jun 2 Thérèse Lalor 16 Nov
 
16/11: Deadline has passed for input regarding dissemination. No further changes to be made
Thérèse Lalor 04 Oct 5 Thérèse Lalor 16 Nov
 
David - The race/ethnicity example was based on the practical difficulty of writing an exhaustive
Helen Toole 20 May 14 Dan Gillman 05 Nov
 
From Tjalling Gelsema: “ For those interested, even after the verdict, please find below
Thérèse Lalor 19 Mar 14 Thérèse Lalor 01 Nov
Further info from Dick. We need to include this in our consideration as agreed above. GSIM
Dick Woensdregt 11 Sep 5 Thérèse Lalor 30 Oct
Discussion 29/10: To keep or not to keep them. This is a well understood in the implementation
Thérèse Lalor 04 Oct 2 Thérèse Lalor 28 Oct
 
Helen has a new picture drawn which is being tweaked.   Updated Quality Diagram.pptx Scenario
Thérèse Lalor 31 Jul 6 Thérèse Lalor 29 Oct
I am surprised nobody has voted for updating the GSIM Communication document. We have a lot
Thérèse Lalor 13 Aug 2 Gareth McGuinness 28 Oct
Further elaboration from CBS: GSIM Issue: Observation Unit is a structured collection In
Thérèse Lalor 04 Oct 5 Thérèse Lalor 28 Oct
The Reference Period is defined as an attribute of StatisticalProgramCycle, it is mentioned
Thérèse Lalor 31 Jul 1 Thérèse Lalor 28 Oct
 
Helen: I agree with Chris from a modelling perspective, but also from a more practical perspective.
Helen Toole 12 Sep 3 Arofan Gregory 17 Oct
CSPA makes a distinction between business function, business process and business service
Dick Woensdregt 11 Sep 4 Thérèse Lalor 04 Oct
I think it is fair to say that Instructions are a specialized form of statement. The reason
Helen Toole 05 Sep 5 Arofan Gregory 03 Oct
The problem with Instrument and InstrumentImplementation is that an instrument is something
Helen Toole 27 Sep 2 Dick Woensdregt 03 Oct
New Definition: The role given to a Represented Variable in the context of a Data Structure to
Jenny Linnerud 17 Sep 2 Jenny Linnerud 02 Oct
2/10 Discussion: Action: We are not making changes to the methodology for this version. We
Jenny Linnerud 19 Feb 8 Thérèse Lalor 02 Oct
 
Discussion 2/10:  Action: Remove and make small text explanation that we may need this in
Thérèse Lalor 07 Mar 17 Thérèse Lalor 02 Oct
start adding definitions that particularly need to be reviewed or that we have agreed need
Thérèse Lalor 02 Oct 0 -
 
Discussion 18/9: Are we ready to resolve this? Is this something for GSIM version after this
Jenny Linnerud 08 Aug 5 Thérèse Lalor 18 Sep
 
Neuchatel Group discussions: Index and Index Entry will renamed to Classification Index and
Thérèse Lalor 22 Aug 2 Thérèse Lalor 13 Sep
Discussion 5/9: GSIM is method agnostic. We should not tie it to any method. Methodology
Thérèse Lalor 31 Jul 2 Thérèse Lalor 05 Sep
Discussion 27/8: Agreed to remove subtypes of population and unit. How is GSIM going to
Jenny Linnerud 21 May 14 Thérèse Lalor 27 Aug

Instructions for use:

  • To reply to a topic, click on the name of the topic in the table below. Then choose 'add comment' and enter your comment in the box. You can choose 'watch this page' to receive email notifications when new responses are posted. Click save to post your reply.
  • To reply to an existing reply (that is, to continue a discussion thread) follow the instructions about but click 'reply' instead of 'add comment'.
  • To create a new topic, click 'add new discussion topic' below. Once you have added the topic, you will need to enter a title in the box at the top that says 'new page'. Then enter your text in the large text box and when you are done, click 'save' at the top right of the text entry box.

 

 

 

Page viewed 7 times by 1 users since 11 Dec, 2013:
Name Last viewed Times viewed
Anonymous 18 Sep, 2014 01:38 7

 


Search this discussion forum

  • No labels