• Suggestions for improving the GSBPM
51 more child pages
Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

Thank you for your comments. The feedback on GSBPM closed on 27 September. You can follow the progress of the discussions on this page. Comments in addition to those below can be sent by e-mail to therese.lalor@unece.org

Discussion Forum

Log (to be updated by Thérèse Lalor only)

 

Background
Object/ Issue
Raised byLast comment
Status
Outcome/current status
Actioned?
Fundamental issue
#1Distinction between 1-3 and 4 - 7 (Design vs Production)Gareth McGuinness18 SeptCONCLUSION TO BE REVIEWED Could add some description to make distinction obvious (and show alignment to GSIM) 
#7Different types of statistical productionThérèse Lalor30 SeptCHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONS

Remove any last survey centric mentions. - UNECE

Potential for additional views/profiles of GSBPM in future.

 
#13Purposes and Use of GSBPMLynne Bismire30 SeptCONCLUSION TO BE REVIEWED

Highlight new purpose and uses - different emphasis now? Add links to other reference models (GSIM, CSPA)

Circle back to this after discussing phases, sub process changes.

 
#19A level below sub processLynne Bismire30 SeptNO CHANGE

Recommend against a level 3 because they are not generic.

Examples of national level 3s to go on the wiki for future revisions.

------
Overarching statistical processes
#2Quality and Metadata ManagementWilhelmus Kloek30 SeptCHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONS

Review paragraphs 41 - 46 (Quality - Wilhelmus Kloek and Nadia Mignolli) and 47 - 48 (Metadata - Jenny Linnerud)

Improve paragraph 13

New Quality text pasted into draft

Still need to add the metadata text and changes to para 13

#15New overarching process: Manage Production ProcessLynne Bismire30 SeptNO CHANGEProject management is listed in paragraph 14 as an overarching process------
Phases
#16Solution focus in Phase 1: Specify NeedsLynne Bismire15 OctCHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONS

Add higher level solution as part of business case text 

Add to descriptions wording about specific populations and legislative requirements to relevant sub processes.

Done
#11Rename Phase 3: Build

Lynne Bismire

Mats Bergdahl

15 OctCHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONSAdd something to paragraph 28 - the introduction to build phase - about reuse - Robert McLellan 
#8Boundaries of phases (particularly Phases 5 - 6)Thérèse Lalor15 OctCONCLUSION TO BE REVIEWED

The split is maybe not quite as simple as micro vs macro because it depends on the type of process survey data vs National accounts.

A number of suggestions about changes to subprocesses so we should come back to this conversation.

 
#10Change scope of phase 7: DisseminationLynne Bismire15 OctCHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONSAdd something about self service by data users in Disseminate. There is some collating of data for the users to select from. See the subprocess suggestion from Gareth McGuinness 
#6Phase 8: ArchiveAlice Born15 OctCHANGE TO MODEL

Business case to be written for the removal of Phase 8 and the addition of an overarching phase,

Gary Dunnet, Eden Brinkley, Mats Bergdahl, Alice Born to review business case

Business case drafted and circulated to the HLG Project Board. This will be presented for approval on 24 October

Phase 8 text removed from new draft.

Still need to finalise overarching phase

#35New Phase: Create StandardsGareth McGuinness15 OctCHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONS

This is a separate piece of work/model - processes that result in standards. This could be more generalised in the HLG work. Future work to given attention.

Action: There are elements of it in some sub processes. Strengthen something around the design phase - Gareth McGuinness

Proposed text added to phase 2 draft
Sub-processes: phases 1 - 4 (see overview picture)
#30Remove finalise subprocesses (3.6, 4.4, 5.8, 6.5)Mats Bergdahl---OPEN TOPIC  
#38Minor change to 1.1 titleMats Bergdahl---CHANGE TO TITLETitle of subprocess to be changed to Identify needsChanged in draft
#25Minor change to 1.6 titleGiorgia Simeoni ---NO CHANGENo change as "for approval" is implied------
#26Switch order of 2.3 and 2.4Giorgia Simeoni  ---NO CHANGEYou do not need to progress through the model in a linear order. Change will confuse more than add------
#39Changes to titles of 2.3, 2.4, 2.5, 2.6Mats Bergdahl---CHANGE TO TITLE Change to title of 2.3, 2.4 and 2.5. No change to 2.6 Titles changed in draft
#21Add design of disclosure control into 2.5

 

Alice Born---CHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONSText to be added to 2.5 and 2.1.  Thérèse Lalor and  Darren Lauzon to propose text added to draft
#18Move instrument building sub process (3.1) to Phase 2Lynne Bismire---NO CHANGENot agreed to------
#36Remove subprocesses 3.2, 3.4, 3.6Gareth McGuinness---CHANGE TO DESCRIPTIONSChange language to be about Services Robert McLellan 
#23Changes to 3.3 and 3.4Nadia Mignolli---CHANGE TO MODEL

New subprocess on dissemination proposed - Nadia Mignolli to draft text

 text added to draft
#28Clarification on 3.5Giorgia Simeoni  ---NO CHANGE Not agreed to ---------
#40Change to title of 4.1Mats Bergdahl---CHANGE TO TITLE Title changed to Create frame and select sample Title changed in draft
#17Validating admin data in Collect sub process 4.3?Lynne Bismire---OPEN TOPIC  
#29Change to description of 4.3Giorgia Simeoni  ---OPEN TOPIC  
#27Clarification on 4.4Giorgia Simeoni  ---OPEN TOPIC  
Sub-processes: phases 5 - 9 (see overview picture)
#49

Change titles of 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4

Mats Bergdahl---NO CHANGE Not agreed to --------
#205.1 Integrate DataWilhelmus Kloek---OPEN TOPIC  
#145.3 Review, validate and editLynne Bismire---OPEN TOPIC  
#41Change description and title of 5.5Mats Bergdahl---OPEN TOPIC  
#24Combine 5.5 and 6.1Nadia Mignolli---Issue merged with Issue 31 -------
#31Move 5.7 to phase 6Mats Bergdahl---OPEN TOPIC  
#32Add seasonal adjustment subprocess to Phase 6Mats Bergdahl---OPEN TOPIC  
#42Change title of 6.2Mats Bergdahl---NO CHANGE Not agreed to --------
#43Change title of 6.3Mats Bergdahl---CHANGE TO TITLE Change title to "interpret and explain outputs" changed in draft
#45Change title of 6.4Mats Bergdahl---NO CHANGE Not agreed to -------
#44Add new subprocess to end of phase 6Mats Bergdahl---OPEN TOPIC  
#37.? Dissemination Services as sub processGareth McGuinness---OPEN TOPIC  
#46Remove sub process 7.1Mats Bergdahl---OPEN TOPIC  
#47Change title of 7.2Mats Bergdahl---NO CHANGE Not agreed to ------
#48Change title of 9.3Mats Bergdahl---VOTE!  
Other
#4Microdata, macrodata...how to include these

Alice Born

Lynne Bismire

25 SeptOPEN TOPIC  
#5View of GSBPMThérèse Lalor27 SeptOPEN TOPIC  
       
#33Where is field management and paradata?Jill Pobjoy---OPEN TOPIC  
#37Where is the frame in the production phaseWilhelmus Kloek---OPEN TOPIC  
       
#9Information on ways to use the model (process modelling)Thérèse Lalor---OPEN TOPIC  
#12Minor Document editingLynne Bismire---BEING REVIEWED AND INCORPORATED BY UNECE  
#22Use Cases or profiles of GSBPMAlice Born---WORK FROM 2014?  
#34Alignment with GSIM terms and mention GSIM where needed

Thérèse Lalor

Gareth McGuinness

---OPEN TOPIC  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page viewed 2090 times by 36 users since 08 Jul, 2013:
Name Last viewed Times viewed
Anonymous 29 Jul, 2014 12:48 1293
Dan Ghergut 20 May, 2014 12:56 2
Eden Brinkley 09 May, 2014 09:04 61
Alice Kovarikova 03 May, 2014 19:06 1
Sebastian Dubrovsky 31 Jan, 2014 06:18 8
Thérèse Lalor 27 Jan, 2014 03:24 203
Steven Vale 21 Jan, 2014 16:48 16
Anne Cheong 09 Dec, 2013 22:58 11
Lynne Bismire 07 Dec, 2013 05:38 61
Gary Dunnet 28 Nov, 2013 17:51 55
Rosemary McGrath 24 Nov, 2013 09:05 2
Gareth McGuinness 20 Nov, 2013 11:05 34
Jenny Linnerud 13 Nov, 2013 14:33 70
Stanislaw Sieluzycki 12 Nov, 2013 21:41 1
Robert McLellan 11 Nov, 2013 22:22 2
Nadia Mignolli 11 Nov, 2013 10:20 15
Darren Lauzon 11 Nov, 2013 06:52 17
Giorgia Simeoni 06 Nov, 2013 14:00 7
Alice Born 05 Nov, 2013 16:41 23
Stela Derivolcov 05 Nov, 2013 14:34 1
Juan Munoz-Lopez 31 Oct, 2013 15:44 13
Fiona Willis-Núñez 25 Oct, 2013 11:52 6
Wilhelmus Kloek 23 Oct, 2013 18:17 21
Jill Pobjoy 23 Oct, 2013 12:28 120
Felipa Zabala 22 Oct, 2013 21:29 1
Mats Bergdahl 14 Oct, 2013 14:28 35
Tatiana Yarmola 10 Oct, 2013 10:57 1
Isabel Morgado 09 Oct, 2013 11:51 1
Pilar Rey del Castillo 26 Sep, 2013 10:05 1
Flavio Rizzolo 06 Sep, 2013 14:52 2
Edwin Aplin 04 Sep, 2013 09:27 1
Marton Vucsan 30 Aug, 2013 09:25 1
John Csaki 23 Aug, 2013 06:39 1
Adam Brown 15 Aug, 2013 21:13 1
John Dunne 14 Aug, 2013 17:48 1
Denis Grofils 05 Aug, 2013 14:40 1
  • No labels