Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

As organisations begin to use GSIM, this discussion forum will be used to explore issues with the model or propose extensions to the model.

Discussion Forum

Add Topic

Add new discussion topic

Excerpt
CSS Stylesheet
#shareContentLink {display: none;}
#add-menu-link {display: none;}


Excerpt
Thank you for your comments. The feedback on GSIM closed on 27 September. You can follow the progress of the discussions on this page. Comments in addition to those below can be sent by e-mail to therese.lalor@unece.org

 

Table Plus

Log (to be updated by Thérèse Lalor only)

TopicBackground
Object/ Issue
Raised byLast comment
Status
Outcome
CommentNon Structured Dataset#6
Non Structured Data SetThérèse Lalor
Status
titleOpen Topic
leaning towards removing objectData Structure Component#34Simplifying data structure component objectsThérèse Lalor29 Oct
Status
titleVoting on options
Revised option added by ABS - for decision. Need to have discussion at #7 first.
Reference Metadata#17CReference MetadataThérèse Lalor29 Oct
Status
titleLow Priority - work required

Can we do an example like we have an example for quality?

Chris says he could have an example from Eurostat - Metadata Structure Definition.

To be discussed at Sprint

Documentation#25GSIMv2 documentationThérèse Lalor13 Sept
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
Vote on which GSIM documents you use the most to help us understand what it useful
Views of GSIM#15Creating views of GSIMGareth McGuinness18 Jul
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
 
Modelling#14Relationships and AttributesJenny Linnerud---
Status
colourRed
titleOpen TopicWaiting
Action: All relationships relationshipsand attributes need to be reviewed and made explicit before next releasePlace holderat Sprint
Modelling#22AttributesObjects to be added/removedThérèse Lalor---
Status
colourRed
titleOpen TopicWaiting
 
Modelling#33DefinitionsThérèse Lalor---
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
 
Action: All attributes definitions need to be reviewed and made explicit before next releasePlace holderat Sprint

Changes to be implemented at Sprint

Instrument Implementation#35Remove all object below Instrument ImplementationDick Woensdregt---
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting

Following agreements made:

** have to make changes with a good business case**

** not going to leave it as it is **

**balance of simple to understand and not leading down the wrong path **

--> Go to Sprint for elaboration

Acquisition Activites#37Review to definition of a number of acquisition related objectsDick Woensdregt11 Oct
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting

What is the outcome here? Is it a change or an acknowledgement?

depends on result of decision at #35

Interviewer Instruction#27Rename Interviewer InstructionHelen Toole2 Oct
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
Arofan has provided input. For discussion - depends on result of decision at #35
Questions#30Question and Multiple Question ItemHelen Toole2 Oct
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting

Input from Arofan and Chris given. Need a resolution based on that advice

depends on result of decision at #35

Data Channel#36

Channel Activity Specification, Channel Design Specification?

Relationship to Data Resource

Dick Woensdregt29 Oct
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Objects related to acquisition decided

Quality#17AQualityThérèse Lalor2 OctProcess Output#19Add Process Output subtypeGareth McGuinness
Status
titleOpen Topic
  
Status
colourGreen
titleOpen Topic
 Placeholder
Reference Metadata#17CReference MetadataThérèse Lalor
Status
titleOpen Topic
 Placeholder
Decided
new text attached to wiki. waiting for picture from Helen
Attribute Component#31Attribute ComponentJenny Linnerud2 Oct
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Jenny has provided an improved definition.

Related to issue #31 and #7

Data Set#7

unit data

dimensional data

Thérèse Lalor11 Oct
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

We agree to the tenet of it and exact changes - in terms of relationships and definitions - to be worked out at sprint. We also need to tighten up all the definitions of dataset related objects.

Statistical Activity#28What is the difference between Statistical Activity and Process Step Execution RecordDick Woensdregt18 Sept
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided
Action: Definition to be improved. we could look into the relationships between these objects. This deserves some attention/discussion.
Process Step#29What does a CSPA Service map to?Dick Woensdregt4 Oct
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

GSIM should add a mention of Statistical Service either to the description or examples of a Business Service

Review text at Sprint to ensure alignment

Methodology#17BMethodologyThérèse Lalor5 Sept
Status
colourGreen
titleOpen Topic
 Place holder
Decided
no changes to be made
Data set#24Distinguishing between different types of datasetsJenny Linnerud

16 Aug

Status
titlecolourOpen TopicGreen
 
title
 
       
Methodology#3Design ContextJenny Linnerud
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
 (Waiting for Methodology discussion to happen before decision made)
Data Set#7

unit data

dimensional data

Thérèse Lalor
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
 Alistair Hamilton
Decided

Are we ready to resolve this? Is this something for GSIM version after this one?

Categorized as future work. Is this something other groups could solve? eg Data without Boundaries or Stats Network

Instrument#32Instrument and Instrument Implementation definitionsHelen Toole2 Oct
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

 Action: fix the table....

Action: Change definition. Better explanatory text around this. 

Action: Rename instrument implementation to represented instrument. It has the advantage of linguistic consistency

Non Structured Dataset#6Non Structured Data SetThérèse Lalor2 Oct
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided
Action: Remove and make small text explanation that we may need this in the future
Node Sets#12Hierarchy in Classifications and codelistsHelen Toole06 Aug
Status
colourRedGreen
titleWaiting
Chris providing example of hierarchical codelist as exampleChris Nelson
Population#13Survey and Frame PopulationsJenny Linnerud
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
ABS to provide improved definitionsAlistair Hamilton
Views of GSIM#15Creating views of GSIMGareth McGuinness
Status
colourRed
titleWaiting
 Waiting for input from CSPA
       
Decided
Action: In the documentation we need to have a good example of what is a classification and what is a codelist (drawn from the the comments at the top of the thread). 
Methodology#3Design ContextJenny Linnerud16 Jul
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided
Action: We are not making changes to the methodology for this version. We should remove this item.
Index/Index Entry#26Index/Index EntryThérèse Lalor13 Sept
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided
 
Population

#1

 

Add unit type object

Alistair Hamilton

 

01 Jul
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

A new object will be added called Unit Type

Action: Definition, relationships and attributed need to be drafted

 
#13Survey and Frame PopulationsJenny Linnerud27 Aug
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

All subtypes of population will be removed

All subtypes of Unit will be remove

#16Add relationship to unit typeHelen Toole4 Jun
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided
Action: Relationship to Logical Record to be added 

Node Sets



#2

Code vs Code List

Category vs Category Set

Klas Blomqvist 13 Aug
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Provide clearer explanation of the differences

Code is kept in the model with better explanation

Action: Text needs to be drafted from examples in discussion forum

 

#8

LevelHelen Toole26 Mar
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Change the diagrams to include Level in the next release.

Action: New diagrams to be created

 
#11Statistical Classification CardinalityHelen Toole

22 Apr

Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Classification Scheme (Statistical Classification) has Mandatory Level

Action: Change the definition of (Statistical Classification) such that it must contain at least one Level.

(Statistical Classification) 1..* Level (Mandatory, Many)

 

Fixed in Neuchatel changes

#21Alignment with NeuchatelThérèse Lalor13 Aug
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Change according to proposal

Action:

Remove Classification Version from model

Remove Classification Variant from model

Change Classification to Classification Series

Change Classification Scheme to Statistical Classification

Revise relationships according to proposal

Add attributes according to proposal

Revise definitions

 
Business Service#4

Business Service

Dissemination Service

Thérèse Lalor09 Apr
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Dissemination Service to be a subtype of Business Service

Action: Text needs to be drafted and attributes aligned

 
Data Resource#5States of dataJenny Linnerud31 Jul
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Information about how states of data "could be done" should go into the next version of the User Guide, rather than trying to fit into the model

Input to be given by countries using states of data may be done.

Action: Text needs to be drafted

 

Data Channel#9Data ChannelThérèse Lalor03 Jul
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Data Channel stays in model

Action: Review definition of Data Channel

 
Representation#10RepresentationThérèse Lalor09 Apr
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Change name of Representation to Presentation

Action: Name changed in documentation and model

 
Data Point#18Data PointHelen Toole16 Jul
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Example in glossary to be fixed (Proposal 1)

Action: Fix Example

 
Process Output#19Add Process Output subtypeGareth McGuinness27 Aug
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

 Remove all subtypes of Process Input

Remove all subtypes of Process Output

Assessment#20AssessmentGareth McGuinness16 Jul
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

Definition to be improved

Action: Fix definition

 
Data Provider#23Data ProviderJenny Linnerud13 Aug
Status
colourGreen
titleDecided

No change to model required. Although perhaps clarification in text would help future users?

Action: clarification in text would help future users?

 

Open Issues

Forum Macro
pageGSIM v1.0 discussion forum
activityIndicatorThreshold5
excludeSubForumsfalse

Instructions for use:

  • To reply to a topic, click on the name of the topic in the table below. Then choose 'add comment' and enter your comment in the box. You can choose 'watch this page' to receive email notifications when new responses are posted. Click save to post your reply.
  • To reply to an existing reply (that is, to continue a discussion thread) follow the instructions about but click 'reply' instead of 'add comment'.
  • To create a new topic, click 'add new discussion topic' below. Once you have added the topic, you will need to enter a title in the box at the top that says 'new page'. Then enter your text in the large text box and when you are done, click 'save' at the top right of the text entry box.

 

 

Viewtracker
hidetrue

 

Show If
currentSpace
groupconfluence-administrators
falsedd-MMM-yyyy

...